Sioux City tried construction manager at risk on its wastewater plant rebuild, didn’t like the price, and went back to hard bid. The gamble looks like it paid. Three bids for Phase 1 of the Wastewater Treatment Plant Facility Plan Improvements were opened Oct. 29, 2026, and the city announced Nov. 10 that PKG Contracting Inc. of Fargo, N.D., came in lowest at $292,376,900.
That’s about 10% below the engineer’s construction estimate of $325 million. Rice Lake Construction Group bid $308.6 million and Hawkins Construction Co. bid $322.7 million, so the spread among the three was tight, which suggests the estimate wasn’t padded and the market for big Midwest water work is competitive right now.
Project Scope
The plant dates to the 1960s and is permitted for roughly 16 million gallons per day of annual average flow, with peaks near 55 mgd. It started life with screening and grit removal, primary clarification, digestion and drying beds, then picked up secondary treatment, disinfection and capacity upgrades over the decades. The facility plan targets odor and safety problems, reliability, nutrient removal for current and future permit limits, replacement of aging structures and equipment, and site improvements. The city expects the work to carry the plant another 30 years.
The program is split into two phases, with a third held for later depending on regional growth. Phase 1 replaces and rehabilitates aging treatment infrastructure. Bidders had to meet State Revolving Fund and American Iron and Steel rules.
Hazen and Sawyer, the city’s engineering consultant, reviewed the bids and contractor qualifications and recommended awarding the base contract to PKG while rejecting all bid alternates. The award still needs City Council approval. The final project budget will add engineering, construction oversight and contingency on top of the construction number.
Why It Matters
The backstory is the interesting part. Kiewit had been the CMAR, and in July the city declined the guaranteed maximum price it submitted. Local reporting put that earlier figure at about $475 million, while Kiewit said its price had been market-tested. The council’s comparison of the two numbers, and who deserves credit for the difference, turned into an open argument at a Nov. 2 meeting.
Contractors should be careful drawing a simple lesson. A GMP and a hard-bid base price don’t carry the same risk, and rejecting every alternate shrinks the scope. Change orders and the final budget will tell whether the savings hold. Still, a 10% beat on a $325 million estimate is a real data point for owners weighing CMAR on process-heavy plants, where the contractor’s early involvement is supposed to be worth paying for.
Related coverage & projects
Project Team & Details
| Owner / Client | City of Sioux City |
|---|
| Consultants | Hazen and Sawyer (Engineering Consultant) |
|---|
| General Contractor | PKG Contracting, Inc. (apparent low bidder; award pending council approval) |
|---|
| Status | Planned |
|---|
| Delivery Method | Design-Bid-Build |
|---|
| Funding Source | Public (Municipal) |
|---|