Cave Creek doesn’t get many new shopping centers. Black Mountain Marketplace is the biggest one the town has seen in a while, and it broke ground this fall on the southeast corner of Cave Creek Road and Carefree Highway, about 30 miles north of downtown Phoenix. Evergreen Development is building the 13.3-acre neighborhood center on behalf of the Bullington family, which owns the land, with completion targeted for summer 2027, Shopping Center Business reported on Nov. 11, 2026.
The anchor isn’t a grocer. It’s a 41,337-square-foot Mountainside Fitness, the Arizona gym chain, which says a lot about what pulls daily traffic to suburban retail now.
Project Scope
Besides the gym, the site plan carries seven outparcel pads for restaurants, services and neighborhood retail. Evergreen says several deals are in progress and only a few drive-thru pads are still open. That’s typical of the format. Pads with a drive-thru lane are what quick-service chains want, and they lease first.
Evergreen is handling planning, entitlement and construction as the family’s development partner. A.R. Mays Construction, the employee-owned Scottsdale general contractor, is building it. Upward Architects designed the center and Hubbard Engineering is the civil engineer.
The entitlement work was its own project. The corner has carried commercial zoning since before Cave Creek incorporated in 1986, but the town still approved a transfer of development rights agreement in May tied to the property. Under that deal, part of the owners’ residential-zoned land on Black Mountain stays open so the hillside views remain, and the project has to keep at least 20% of the site undisturbed. The developer also produced a native plant inventory and salvage plan, with cacti and trees set aside on site until they can be replanted. Water for development south of Carefree Highway comes from the City of Phoenix, so the town’s own supply isn’t touched.
Why It Matters
For Cave Creek it’s mostly about sales tax. The town’s commercial base is small, and KTAR reported that officials expect the center to significantly improve its sales tax base.
For the broader market, the anchor choice is the story. Big-box fitness has become a dependable replacement for the grocery or department store anchor in Sun Belt neighborhood centers, because members show up several times a week and spill over into the food pads. Whether that holds through a softer economy is a fair question. But it’s what lenders and pad tenants are underwriting right now, and this center’s leasing pace suggests it’s working on Carefree Highway.
Related coverage & projects
Project Team & Details
| Developer | Evergreen Development |
|---|
| Owner / Client | Bullington family |
|---|
| Architect | Upward Architects |
|---|
| Consultants | Hubbard Engineering (Civil Engineering) |
|---|
| General Contractor | A.R. Mays Construction |
|---|
| Status | Under Construction |
|---|
| Funding Source | Private |
|---|